Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.

About Stacie

Stacie Schlichtenmyer Warsaw, IN Real Estate Agent Headshot

Meet Stacie

A Place to Be Present

By Sarah Marty Schlipf
 
Stacie Schlichtenmyer started Lake City Real Estate, backed by Keller Williams Realty, one of the largest brokerages in the world. With over 15 years of healthcare experience before entering real estate, her instinct has always been to serve first. Whether she’s with a client, her team, or her community, she shows up the same way: ready to help.
 
She works with real people navigating real life: empty nesters ready to rightsize into something that actually fits, families relocating from out of state who need someone who truly knows this market, first-time investors ready to start building wealth, and longtime homeowners finally ready to make their next move. Stacie specializes in lake and waterfront properties across Kosciusko County. Her approach goes beyond the transaction; she’s in the business of helping people write the next chapter of their story through intentional real estate planning.
 
In 2026, Stacie and a couple of other local agents had an opportunity to open a new independent Keller Williams office in downtown Warsaw—a space built for collaborative, growth-minded agents who want more than a desk: a community where they can learn, grow, and build something meaningful with support and resources. When she’s not with clients or helping other agents, she’s outside being active with her family. Whether on the water with the Lake City Skiers—Indiana’s only competitive water ski team—or volunteering with The Watershed Foundation to protect the lakes and streams that make Kosciusko County worth calling home.

Stacie Schlichtenmyer

REALTOR®
PHONE
(574) 334-7105
EMAIL
[email protected]
LICENSE NUMBER
RB22001879
ADDRESS
212 S Buffalo St, Warsaw, IN 46580

Testimonials

  • previous
  • next
  • Buying a home is one of the biggest decisions a family can make, and I truly cannot imagine going through this journey with anyone other than Stacie. From the very beginning, she was always available whenever we had questions, concerns, or simply needed reassurance. There were moments during our home-buying process that felt overwhelming, especially when unexpected challenges came up, but Stacie never backed down. She fought for our family every step of the way, making sure our best interests always came first. She explained everything with patience, advocated for us when we needed someone in our corner, and gave us the confidence to keep moving for...
    — Miranda
  • Our realtor was amazing; she was there every step of the way for us. She explained things we didn't understand because it was our first time buying a home. If you ever need a real estate agent, I suggest going there.
    — Shyla Y.
  • Stacie was prompt in her responses. Knew what I was looking for and was honest and up front about what she thought the houses I looked at should be valued at. I leaned on her expertise throughout the process.
    — Buyer
  • Stacie is such a great realtor to work with. She’s helped connect me with referral partners in other states and is genuinely selfless in helping others.
    — Kate R.
  • Stacie is an awesome agent with a servant's heart! She goes the extra mile for her clients and is always striving to improve and offer more value!
    — Emmanuel R.
  • Stacie has been a great partner to my business, and through everything, she continues to put her clients' needs first. When people say you need a realtor, Stacie is exactly what they envision.
    — Sam H.
  • Stacie has been a joy to work with. She’s so courteous and genuine. My family loves her.
    — Jenipher H.
VIEW ALL
main

A Place to Be Present

Stacie Schlichtenmyer first fell in love with lake life as a teenager, when her parents bought a little place on Portage Lake in southern Michigan, not far from where she grew up. Years later, after her career brought her to Warsaw, she settled on Pike Lake with her husband and daughter.

“It’s just gorgeous,” Stacie says. From her home on the channel, she can open her back doors onto sweeping views of the water. With limited speeds and minimal development, Pike is also peaceful and quiet, a nature lover’s lake. “There’s so much wildlife,” she marvels. Eagles fly over, and we have a heron that hangs out by us.”

When Stacie learned to water ski, she discovered a new passion and a new way to appreciate lake life. Last year, she joined the Lake City Skiers, a local water ski show team. “It’s so fun!” she laughs, remembering climbing her teammates’ shoulders on her very first day of practice. She loves the challenge, the camaraderie, and the way her teammates help her learn and grow. “Everyone there absolutely loves skiing, and they love being with other people who love skiing.”

Skiing also gives Stacie a way to unplug. As a REALTOR® with a thriving business, it can be tough to disconnect from work–but she can’t answer her phone on skis. Every Wednesday morning in summer, Stacie drives to nearby Hidden Lake, stashes her device, and sits by the water until it’s time to begin practice. “To be somewhere and be present is so important for me,” she says. On those mornings, “There’s nowhere else in the world I’d rather be.”

main

Finding Connection and Community

Stacie attended her first meeting of the Pike Lake Association in 2017, not long after she bought her home. That’s where she learned about the challenges facing her lake, like pollution carried in from Deeds Creek, which threatens Pike’s long-term health. “This affects my daughter, my family, my community. What do we need to do?” Stacie asked. “What can I do?”

She quickly connected with The Watershed Foundation, joining the mailing list, volunteering to collect water quality data, and eventually joining the Board of Directors in 2022. Now she’s an at-large executive member, serves on multiple committees, and helps with events like Rafting Week and the annual Cottage Tours.

Through her work with TWF, Stacie has learned more about water quality issues across the watershed, as well as the people and organizations working hard to protect local lakes. “I want to know everything,” she says. “I’m thirsty for knowledge.” That knowledge helps her serve her real estate clients too. “Education is a huge part of what I do. The most insignificant part of my job is opening the door to a house.”

Like skiing, volunteering has also given Stacie a sense of community, a way to be part of something bigger than herself. It connects her with like-minded, passionate people who invest in what matters most to them. “You only have so much time,” she points out. She chooses to spend hers on what she loves. We’re grateful to Stacie for giving her time to care for our lakes and communities!

Browse My Portfolio

  • previous
  • next
VIEW ALL

Find Your Next Dream Home

Search Homes

Work With Stacie

With a heart for service and deep expertise in Kosciusko County, she helps clients navigate lake, waterfront, and residential real estate with confidence. From first-time buyers to investors and those ready for their next chapter, she provides thoughtful guidance and intentional real estate planning every step of the way.
Let's Connect

Follow Me on Instagram

Contact Details

Stacie Schlichtenmyer

Phone

(574) 334-7105

Email

[email protected]

Address

212 S Buffalo St Warsaw, IN 46580

Submit a Message

Message sent successfully!